I actually have to turn a light on to write in the morning again when I am getting it in before work! Fall, what do you do to me after you lure me in with changing leaves, cool air, pumpkin patch trips and hoodies is you bundle me back up into the cold darkness of what is going to be a long cold season where I live.
Also, my son reached his sixth birthday yesterday so the weekends have been birthday and Halloween shenanigans. He chose a Jack Skellington costume due to his being my child and loving the small bits of macabre that I allow to him. I couldn’t believe Wal Mart had a Jack Skellington costume, and there was only one, but another excellent thing about my child is he doesn’t hem and haw about what to be for Halloween. He chooses something and sticks to it, and the last two years he has truly had a choice, I have agreed with it wholeheartedly. So that Jack costume launched itself into my cart with alacrity. And like every mother it is hard to believe that they pulled him out of me and he changed me as a person six years ago already.
For this post, I read two books that have been camping out on my TBR forever featuring Edgar Allan Poe as protagonists. And yes, I realize that this post may have been better earlier in the month, closer to the anniversary of his mysterious death. Anything to do with EAP is sure to be dark. He is the 8th grade student’s hero with his brooding darkness and his tales that make kids realize that maybe all old literature isn’t terrible and boring and unrelateable. Like, a guy who seals someone in a wall for revenge? Someone who thinks they can hear the beating heart of someone they murdered coming from the floor panels? Sweet! And if kids read up on his life a little I think he is even more fit to be a broody, morbid and dark young teenager’s hero: he struggles for a place in the world, is very smart, very moody, with a razor sharp sarcasm that he used even on his supposed ‘betters’ as a staunch literary critic. These elements also make it unsurprising that multiple authors have chosen him for their historical fiction novels, combined with the fact that these are both mysteries and Poe himself was one of the first writers of detective fiction. In this blog I review two:
Poe Must Die, Marc Olden
This one was actually written in the 1970s and I had no idea it was that old when I downloaded it to read. In this one, a prizefighter in England comes to 1830’s NYC to seek revenge on a man who was responsible for the death of his wife and son, and he is referred to EA Poe by Charles Dickens as someone who can help. They start off as an unlikely pair but of course get to appreciate and look out for one another. By the 1830’s, Poe’s young wife had died of TB and he was untethered and despairing, having given himself over to grief and substance use, the fame of The Raven still present but waning. He has investment in stopping the same antagonist, a powerful man who is also setting to find supernatural secrets and have dark and demonic supernatural powers, and has chosen a young beautiful widow that Poe has some interest in to dupe into helping him reach his goal of complete power and takeover. Both men have nothing to lose by seeking to stop and kill him. Most men in this novel have a reason they could want Poe dead, and some of them try to kill him off and some of them don’t. The antagonist instead chooses to try to drive him mad by convincing him the ghost of his dead wife is outside his home at night.
Both of these books deal with NYC in the early 1800s, back when it was all muddy streets and the usual combination of extreme haves and extreme have nots. I love the history of NYC, and in these books it is so new that it is even still forested, especially in the next book I talk about, which takes place years earlier than this one. They involve the same infamous slums that Poe frequented and both talk about the same event where Poe was face down in an animal fighting ring, although one book says that he willingly drank himself there and the second book suggests that he was drugged against his will. It is a completely plausible setting for a plot of someone seeking supernatural dark power and doing everything to get it.
On Night’s Shore, Randall Silvis
This one takes place a little earlier in time, so NYC is still even more muddy and wooded, although the decaying Brewery and Five Points are still featured settings in the city, and Poe’s wife Virginia is still alive as a convalescent. And although he is writing, he hasn’t hit his fame yet with The Raven. He is still trying to make it as a freelance writer and sell his work when he is low on money.
This one is also lighter. There is no antagonist looking to raise power to be equal to the dark forces or baiting people Poe loves into death, no resurrection, no hostage taking of dead bodies. It is told from the perspective of a ten year old street urchin who, as one might expect, is also trying to find his place in the world, and befriends Poe to help solve the mysterious death of a young woman. He also falls in love with Poe’s little corner of domesticity with his mother in law and his wife, a loving and cozy life that the boy has never known in his ten years.
There are some dark and terrible things that happen, but the villains involved are the usual power drunk white men who are looking to have fun with no consequence and amass as much wealth and influence as possible. More run of the mill reasons for murder, not, like, trying to find immortality, although in some of the cozies I read last year immortality was a more typical antagonist goal than in other books.
At least I posted on Poe books in the same month of his mysterious disappearance and death, even if it wasn’t earlier in the month. If Poe was truly a sleuth in his life, equipped with his razor tongue and wit, a mysterious death of his own and a tragically short life himself doesn’t surprise me. Also I have downloaded some of Poe’s detective novels, hailed as some of the first in the genre, because these fictionalized, although holding true to basic facts stories, intrigue me to look into more of his writing.
I hope everyone is enjoying their Halloween season! Two more Halloween reads to post on, so stay tuned if you are enjoying scary reads October.